Why Aluminum Foil Has a Dull Side and a Shiny Side - Reynolds Aluminum Foil Wrap

Consider the mystery solved.
According to Reynold's Kitchen, the difference between the two sides of aluminum foil is just a result of manufacturing.

People are just realising what you should use each side of tin foil for

Reviews for Reynolds 37.5 sq. ft. Non-Stick Grilling Aluminum Foil

Is There a Difference Between Tin Foil and Aluminum Foil? – LifeSavvy

The Reason Aluminum Foil Has Both A Shiny And Dull Side

Is There A Right And Wrong Side Of Aluminum Foil?

For over 70 years, home cooks have trusted the strength, versatility and durability of Reynolds Wrap Aluminum Foil throughout their homes; now, trust

Reynolds Wrap Everyday Strength Non-Stick Aluminum Foil, 150 Square Feet

Can Aluminum Foil Go In The Oven?

Why Aluminum Foil Has a Dull Side and a Shiny Side - Reynolds Aluminum Foil Wrap

Reynold's Finally Settles the Debate: This Is What Each Side of Aluminum Foil Is For

What You Should Know About Aluminum Foil

Why Aluminum Foil Is Shiny On One Side While Dull On The Other?

Why is only 1 side of aluminum foil shiny?